Pros & Cons: Embarking on an Independent Journey vs. Utilizing a Surrogacy Agency

Worldwide Surrogacy Specialists


Embarking on the journey of becoming a gestational surrogate is a profound decision that requires careful thought and understanding of the available options. Among the choices that women encounter in the world of surrogacy, a significant one is whether to pursue an independent path or work alongside a reputable surrogacy agency. Below, we will explore the pros and cons of an independent surrogacy journey as well as working with an agency, shedding light on the nurturing support that is crucial every step of the way.

At Worldwide Surrogacy Specialists, we wholeheartedly believe in the transformative power of surrogacy and the profound impact it has on individuals and families. We approach our role as advisors with a deep sense of moral responsibility, driven by our unwavering belief that choosing to embark on a journey assisted by an agency is the safest and most rewarding path for potential surrogates. However, we understand how important it is to understand the full variety of options when it comes to your journey, and we want to serve as an educational resource for anyone considering experiencing the life-changing world of surrogacy.

Independent Surrogacy

Independent surrogacy involves the process of finding intended parents without initial assistance from such professionals as surrogacy agencies, doctors, or lawyers. This approach can include both matches made between relatives or close friends and connections made through online platforms, social media, or mutual acquaintances. While independent surrogacy may work out successfully in some cases, it is essential to recognize the inherent risks involved due to the absence of professional and knowledgeable supervision and support.

Pros of Independent Surrogacy

Familiarity: Independent surrogacy often unfolds between individuals who already share a deep bond, such as family members or close friends. This pre-existing relationship creates a sense of trust and familiarity between the surrogate and prospective parents, infusing the journey with a profoundly personal touch.

Flexibility: Without agency involvement, both the surrogate and intended parents may have greater control over the terms and conditions of their surrogacy arrangement. This flexibility allows for direct negotiation and customization of the agreement, empowering all parties involved.

Cons of Independent Surrogacy

Limited Professional Guidance: Opting for independent surrogacy means forgoing the expertise and support provided by surrogacy agencies. The absence of professionals can lead to insufficient screening of both surrogates and intended parents, unwelcome legal complexities, and added emotional challenges during the journey.

Increased Risk of Disputes: In the absence of a well-structured agreement and professional guidance and support, disputes regarding financial matters, medical expenses, or legal procedures may arise. Such conflicts can strain relationships and create irreparable damage between once-close friends or family members.

Lack of Emotional Support: Surrogacy is an emotionally demanding experience for all involved. Pursuing an independent path may result in a lack of emotional support and guidance for the surrogate, as she may not have a dedicated support network to help address her concerns and provide assistance throughout the process.

Lack of Guidance: Some independent matches are made between people who do not know one another. Such people may find one another on the internet or through mutual acquaintances. Matches such as these present additional risks that may not be adequately addressed if the parties are not screened according to accepted standards, and if the arrangement is not supervised and managed by a team of knowledgeable professionals at a well-regarded surrogacy agency.

It’s important to remember that while some independent matches do work out fine, proceeding without the involvement of an experienced agency, with a legal advisor on hand as part of the agency team, creates a great deal of enhanced risk.

Surrogacy Agencies

Engaging with a surrogacy agency offers surrogates a nurturing support system, professional guidance, and a structured framework for their surrogacy journey. Reputable agencies possess the experience and knowledge required to navigate the complex process, ensuring the well-being and protection of all parties involved. 

Why is it important for a woman to seriously consider that it will be best for her to work with a surrogacy agency? 

A good surrogacy agency is experienced and devoted to making sure that all parties stay protected, informed, and safe throughout the surrogacy journey. Another important attribute of an effective surrogacy agency is one that has a legal staff so that the legal complexities may be addressed at any time.

The American Society for Reproductive Medicine sets forth guidelines, including advice and recommendations regarding the medical, legal, and ethical aspects of surrogacy. Mainstream, reputable, and experienced surrogacy agencies follow these guidelines to ensure that women who become surrogates and the intended parents with whom they are matched are well attended to, supported, informed, and taken care of throughout this most intimate and complicated life-changing endeavor of bringing a baby into the world through gestational surrogacy.

Pros of Utilizing a Surrogacy Agency

Professional Guidance and Encouragement: Surrogacy agencies provide extensive expertise and support throughout the surrogacy process. They facilitate comprehensive screening, thorough matching, and ongoing case management, ensuring that surrogates are well-informed, protected, and supported at every step of their transformative journey.

Enhanced Legal Protection: Working with an agency means assurance of having access to independent legal representation. Surrogates have a right to benefit from having their own attorney to advise them on the surrogacy agreement, their rights, and obligations. This legal counsel helps ensure that the surrogate's interests are carefully safeguarded. The legal protection includes making sure that the surrogates receive all of their compensation fully and on time.

Medical and Insurance Assistance: Surrogacy agencies maintain close relationships with reputable medical clinics and insurance professionals. They assist in coordinating medical appointments, reviewing insurance coverage, and addressing any potential billing issues, thus minimizing confusion and ensuring the surrogate's overall well-being.

Emotional and Psychological Support: The emotional aspects of surrogacy can be intricate and challenging. Surrogacy agencies provide surrogates with dedicated case managers and support staff who regularly check in, offering emotional support and facilitating open communication between the surrogate and the intended parents. These agencies also provide counseling services to help surrogates navigate the emotional journey, addressing any concerns or difficulties that may arise with empathy and understanding.

Cons of Utilizing a Surrogacy Agency

Higher Cost for Intended Parents: Working with a surrogacy agency involves additional expenses, including agency fees and legal fees. These higher costs may deter some intended parents who can't afford the agency route. However, surrogates are not impacted by this.

Less Flexibility in Match Selection: Surrogacy agencies typically have a pool of intended parents who have been thoroughly screened, vetted and are waiting to be matched. While this ensures a higher level of reliability, it also means that surrogates may have less control over the selection process compared to independent surrogacy, where there are no standards set in place for matching parents.


Choosing between independent surrogacy and surrogacy assisted by an agency is a deeply personal decision for potential surrogates. While independent surrogacy offers familiarity in some cases,  and flexibility, it comes with risks and challenges that may be mitigated by working with a reputable agency. Surrogacy assisted by an agency can provide surrogates with professional guidance, legal protection, medical support, and emotional assistance, but it also may entail potentially less control.

It is crucial for potential surrogates to weigh the pros and cons of each option, considering their personal circumstances, preferences, and existing support networks. Ultimately, the decision should prioritize the well-being, safety, and fulfillment of the surrogate, as well as the best interests of the intended parents and the future child. Seeking advice from surrogacy professionals, consulting with experienced surrogates, and exploring the various available resources can help potential surrogates make an informed choice that best aligns with their individual goals and values.

Remember, whichever path a surrogate chooses, the journey of surrogacy is a remarkable and selfless act that can bring joy and fulfillment to all parties involved. It is a testament to the boundless love and compassion within the human spirit.

See if You Qualify →

Get the Latest Updates

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

become a surrogate

gestational surrogacy

gestational surrogate


how to become a surrogate

Worldwide Surrogacy Specialists

See if You Qualify →

"Thank you for everything. All of your staff has been very helpful and outstandingly nice! I can't wait to continue this journey with your group."




Start Your Application

Interested in seeing if you qualify to become a gestational surrogate? Take this 2-minute quiz to see if you qualify!
Start the Application

Intended Parents

Request a Consultation

Interested in starting or building your family through surrogacy? Schedule a consultation today to meet our team and learn more.
Schedule a Consultation